Mary is much more central to the story than in Matthew with her visit to Elizabeth and her Magnificat in 1:46-55. Start studying The Birth of Jesus: Comparing Matthew and Luke's Narratives. Matthew and Luke’s birth narratives have many obvious differences when you first read them. Luke. God saves (Matthew) Emmanuel means.. (story) God is with us (Matthew) After Jesus' birth in Bethlehem the family flees to Egypt (because angel warned them) and then return to Istael after Herod dies, instead go to Nazareth because Archalaus was ruling. Luke’s narrative is about three times as long as Matthew’s and therefore usually receives more attention. The two lengthy chapters that begin Luke’s account contain stories relating the births of Jesus and his predecessor, John the Baptist. Similarity #3. Differentiated resources available. At the very least, the tradition predates both Luke and Matthew, who draw on a common tradition. Between these two accounts they are still portraying two different point of views. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Mark, it will be recalled, begins with Jesus as an adult.

Matthew. Luke's account, the most popularly known, includes the angel's visit to Mary, the world-wide census, the birth in the manger in Bethlehem, the angels' visit to the shepherds, and the shepherd's visitation to the stable. Luke’s Birth Narrative in Comparative Perspective. In Luke he was visited by shepherds, and in Matthew he was visited by magi. The greatest difference between the gospels is Luke’s coverage of Jesus’ Judean ministry which is unique to his gospel (10:1 – 18:14). So Mary and Elizabeth are notable, but Zecheriah goofs, and Joseph is a bit player in Luke, whereas in matthew Joseph is the man receiving key dreams, the magi are also well guided, but Mary is … The first difference we see is that Matthew starts with the genealogy of Christ. I spent time comparing and contrasting them, along with Christmas Carols from the Moravian Book of Worship. There is a heavy focus on the naming of John before we're told of Jesus' birth. Each presents a different portrait of Jesus. Behind these differences lies a powerful picture of the life and death of Jesus and what he came to achieve. In this brief post I want to highlight a few of the similarities and differences in these birth narratives. (If memory serves correct, even Charlie Brown quotes from Luke and ignores Matthew.) These are brief notes, but I … We find the accounts of Jesus' birth in Matthew and Luke. They are brief at best. That person’s family background or the circumstances prevailing either in the community or wider world, or indeed both Each addresses a different Christian community. Together they offer a rich plurality of portraits. The problem people have with reading these two accounts, usually, is the problem they… Gospel of Matthew In Luke’s account he starts off with the birth of John, but in Matthews account he starts off with traces of Joseph’s family tree. > How do Matthew's and Luke's infancy narratives differ? Of the four Gospels only Matthew and Luke give us narratives of Jesus’ birth. The author goes to considerable length to explain the background and circumstances around John's birth before coming to Jesus. The Literary Relationship of Matthew, Mark, and Luke. In two previous posts I’ve detailed what happens in Luke’s version of Jesus’ birth and then in Matthew’s. The author goes to considerable length to explain the background and circumstances around John's birth before coming to Jesus. Luke’s and Matthew’s birth narratives of the Savior are quite different.